18.5IMDbPG-13The Prestige
2006
Top 9 American Mystery Movies
Looking for the best american mystery movies? We've ranked the standouts by rating — led by The Prestige (2006) — so you can find your next watch fast. Every title includes its rating and honest age certification.
9 movies · ranked by rating
- 18.5IMDbPG-13
27.5IMDbREyes Wide Shut
1999
37.4IMDbPGZootopia 2
2025
47.4IMDb16The Wailing
2016
56.0IMDbRHallow Road
2025
66.8IMDbRThe Housemaid
2025
76.7IMDbRMarrowbone
2017
86.2IMDbR
96.6IMDbPG-13
Frequently asked questions
What is the best American Mystery movie?
The Prestige (2006) tops our ranking of the best American Mystery movies, based on a weighted blend of IMDb and TMDb ratings. The Prestige, Eyes Wide Shut and Zootopia 2 round out the top picks.
How are these American Mystery movies ranked?
We rank by a weighted rating that combines IMDb and TMDb scores with how many people voted — so well-loved, widely-seen films rank above obscure titles with a high score from only a handful of votes. Every pick also shows its official age rating.
What are some good American Mystery movies to watch?
Beyond The Prestige, our list above highlights the highest-rated American Mystery movies worth your time, each with its rating and age certification noted.